Plate Nº 36 · recorded November 18, 2026
Space & AstronomyReported finding
Gravitational-Wave Data Point to Black Holes From Failed Supernovae
Among 257 detected black-hole mergers, 75% involved 10-solar-mass objects; a mass gap at 12 to 16 solar masses and distinct spins point toward failed supernovae.
By Priya Raman3 min read661 words
In brief
- Researchers examined 257 black-hole mergers recorded over 10 years, within a catalog of more than 300 collisions logged since 2015.
- Black holes at 10 solar masses represented 75% of the sample.
- Objects between 12 and 16 solar masses were unexpectedly scarce.
- The 10-solar-mass population showed a distinct range of spin speeds.
- The paper appeared Nov. 10 in Physical Review D and called for more research.

Black holes with about 10 times the Sun’s mass represented 75% of 257 black-hole mergers in a new gravitational-wave study, a pattern consistent with stars collapsing without exploding.
The analysis, led by Katerina Chatziioannou, a member of the LIGO team at the California Institute of Technology, examined 10 years of mergers recorded by LIGO, Virgo and KAGRA. LIGO means Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory; KAGRA means Kamioka Gravitational Wave Detector. Virgo and KAGRA are LIGO’s gravitational-wave detector partners.
Those instruments detect gravitational waves (ripples in spacetime produced by distant cosmic events). The network has recorded more than 300 black-hole collisions since the detectors first heard such ripples in 2015. The study focuses on 257 of those mergers.
The standard account begins when a massive star runs out of fuel for nuclear fusion. Its core collapses while its outer layers expand. Shock waves from the collapse strike those layers, trigger a supernova explosion, and leave a collapsed core that becomes a black hole. The new analysis suggests this sequence does not explain every black-hole birth.
Chatziioannou said: “A vast majority of the merging black holes in the universe are about 10 times the mass of our sun. Our data are showing that this group of black holes may have a common origin — they may be a distinct subpopulation that failed to go supernova.”
The findings also connect gravitational-wave measurements with astrophysics (the physics of stars and other cosmic objects). Chatziioannou called the prospect of better understanding black-hole formation in extreme cosmic environments exciting, though the evidence remains indirect.
What does a failed supernova mean?
A failed supernova is the direct collapse of a massive star without an explosion. The star implodes, or collapses inward, and can form a black hole. No hard evidence currently establishes that such events occur, although theory supports the idea. Astronomers expect a vast population of massive stars to die this way.
These may include the roughly 10-solar-mass black holes found in merging pairs. Finding them directly would be difficult because the stars simply vanish, leaving what Legred described as a dark patch of sky rather than an observable explosion. Astronomers can search historical records, but the events remain hard to identify.
What did the merger data reveal?
The team first measured how merger masses were distributed across 257 events. A solar mass means the mass of the Sun. The distribution reached a peak at 10 solar masses, and black holes at that mass represented 75% of the sample. The concentration appeared consistent with expectations. The scarcity of objects from 12 to 16 solar masses did not.
Isaac Legred of the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign said: “We see 10 solar-mass black holes merging all the time. But why are, say, 14 solar-mass black holes so rare?” He proposed that a special combination of internal stellar physics could create that abundance of 10-solar-mass objects.
The researchers then compared spin, the rate at which each black hole rotates. The 10-solar-mass black holes occupied a distinct range of spin speeds. The team interpreted this as an indication of a common origin, perhaps the implosion of a massive star without a supernova explosion.
What remains uncertain?
The analysis shows that gravitational-wave data are consistent with most binary black holes—two black holes that merge—forming through a particular kind of failed supernova. It does not settle the question. Legred concluded that more research is needed, while the theory still lacks hard evidence for individual failed explosions.
The team published the research on Tuesday, Nov. 10, in Physical Review D. Direct proof remains difficult because failed supernovae leave neither an explosion nor an easy historical marker. Their proposed signature instead comes indirectly from the masses and spins of merging black holes.
The pattern remains suggestive rather than definitive, but it gives astronomers a way to test stars that may have vanished without an explosion.
via space.com (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in general science news at SciBeat.
476 articles
Nearby plates
- Black Holes May Be Born in Silence When Giant Stars Skip the Fireworks
- Quiet Deaths: Some Massive Stars May Collapse Without Exploding
- Black Hole Mass Gap Hints at Stars That Died Silently
- 257 Black Hole Mergers Point to Stars That Died Without Exploding
- Early star collisions may seed supermassive black holes