Plate Nº 91 · recorded November 17, 2026
Science Policy & FundingReported finding
Locked phone pouches recover 1-2 weeks of learning per year, study says
Locking phones in pouches may recover 1-2 weeks of learning a year, a study of 3 million students finds — but a peer-reviewed rival study saw near-zero gains, and the new paper isn't reviewed yet.
By James Calloway4 min read802 words
In brief
- Study released Tuesday found locked phone pouches recover roughly 1-2 weeks of learning per year.
- Researchers analyzed more than 3 million students over five school years across 844 Yondr pouch schools using NWEA tests.
- A peer-reviewed April study found "close to zero" test score impact from the same pouches.
- U.S. teen smartphone access jumped from under 25% in 2011 to 95% by 2018; scores began sliding around 2013.
- Pouches cost roughly $25 per student; more than 3,300 schools adopted them between 2019-20 and 2025-26.

Locking students' phones in pouches during the school day may restore the equivalent of one to two weeks of learning per year, according to a study released Tuesday. That is the headline number. It is small — but statistically significant, its authors insist.
"Around 2013, U.S. students started losing 2-3 weeks of learning each year," says Tom Kane of Harvard University, a co-author. "It's been a slow leak that, over time, has put U.S. 8th graders almost a year behind. Strict cellphone bans seem to plug about half of that leak."
The leak, he means, dates to the smartphone era. Roughly 95% of teens had smartphone access by 2018, up from under a quarter in 2011, and achievement slid alongside that spread.
Who did the study, and how?
Researchers from Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research, Dartmouth College and the testing organization NWEA analyzed more than 3 million elementary, middle and high school students across the past five school years. They compared test scores at schools that adopted lockable phone pouches with scores at similar schools that did not. The authors call it the first nationwide study to use student-level math and reading scores from before and after these bans took effect.
The gains did not fade after year one, Kane says. They appeared to persist — at least up to three years after adoption. "That could add up over time, just as the initial declines did," adds Dartmouth's Douglas Staiger, another co-author.
Here comes the caveat. The study has not been peer-reviewed.
Why another study found nothing
An April study — this one peer-reviewed — examined the same pouches and found "close to zero" impact on test scores. "Overall, we didn't find evidence of meaningful achievement gains," says Brian Jacob of the University of Michigan, a co-author.
Both studies looked at pouches made by Yondr, a for-profit company. More than 3,300 schools nationwide adopted them between the 2019-20 and 2025-26 school years. Students typically lock their phones in at the start of the day; an administrator unlocks the pouches with a magnetic device at dismissal.
The studies differ in design, which partly explains the clash:
- The April study pooled school-level average scores across several thousand Yondr schools — a bigger sample.
- Tuesday's study used finer-grained, student-level scores at 844 schools that use both Yondr pouches and NWEA tests.
The findings also overlap more than the headlines suggest. Jacob's team did find statistically significant high school math gains from the pouches — offset, they concluded, by learning losses in middle school.
Jacob calls the new study "encouraging. And if [the benefit] really persists and accumulates over time, it really could be a meaningful benefit. I think we'll just have to wait and see if that happens."
Stanford's Tom Dee, also a co-author of the April paper, is blunter. "I hope they are right that these very small test score gains will aggregate and add up over time. However, I'm not comfortable making that extrapolation from estimates that are small, sensitive and based on just a few years of phone bans." Taken together, he calls the early results "largely disappointing" and says "we need continued study on this topic."
What happened in 2013?
For over two decades, from 1990 to 2013, fourth- and eighth-grade math scores rose steadily, and reading improved too. Then came a sustained slide, one that continued through the pandemic and has only recently slowed.
Pandemic closures got the political blame. The data points elsewhere. "Particularly in reading, test scores were going down for four to six years before the pandemic," Stanford researcher Sean Reardon told NPR earlier this year. "In fact, you wouldn't really know there was a pandemic effect if you just looked at the last 10 or 12 years of test scores."
Smartphones are only one suspect among several. The federal government also retreated from holding schools accountable for low scores, and many districts absorbed funding cuts after the Great Recession. Similar achievement declines hit other industrialized countries with similar smartphone adoption rates — consistent with the phone theory, though not proof of it.
What does this change for schools?
Kane's answer is financial. The pouches cost roughly $25 per student, and even a small benefit, he argues, beats the alternative: "That's still a lot less than having to pay teachers for an extra week or two of instruction."
Fair point. But with one peer-reviewed study finding near-zero effects and the other unreviewed, principals buying pouches this fall are placing a modest bet on unfinished science. Kane says he next wants to study students' smartphone and social media use outside of school — where most of the damage, if any, may actually occur.
via feeds.npr.org (Source)
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on general science news at SciBeat.
474 articles
Nearby plates
- School Phone Bans Add a Week or Two of Learning, Study Finds
- More Daily Steps Linked to Fewer Teen Mental Health Problems
- Permanent Daylight Saving Time Could Mean 2 Billion Dark School Commutes
- Swedish Twin Study Suggests Screen Time's Mental Health Link May Be Overstated
- Your Child's School May Shape How Far You Think They'll Go