Plate Nº 12 · recorded November 18, 2026

Neuroscience & MindReported finding

Punishment deters less when crime feels morally motivated

UC San Diego's Rady School reports across 10 studies that people acting from moral conviction respond far less to punishment than those motivated by money.

By Marcus Bennett4 min read793 words

In brief

  1. A 2026 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences paper from UC San Diego's Rady School of Management reports findings from 10 studies
  2. Analysis of federal crime data covering more than 30,000 offenders across 29 categories linked morally motivated crimes to higher rearrest rates
  3. In an experiment, 422 participants who imagined blocking traffic for a cause they believed in were less deterred by possible consequences
  4. Facing a possible financial penalty, participants were about 20 percentage points more likely to redistribute money when the unequal split was deliberate
  5. Results were similar for participants with prior misdemeanor or felony convictions; paper DOI 10.1073/pnas.2624057123
Why punishment doesn't always prevent crime
Plate Nº 12Why punishment doesn't always prevent crime — lechenie-narkomanii / pixabay

A financial penalty barely dents willingness to act when the actor believes a wrong needs righting: in one experiment, people facing a possible penalty were about 20 percentage points more likely to redistribute money when the unequal split had been deliberate than when it came at random.

That gap anchors a paper published in 2026 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences by researchers at UC San Diego's Rady School of Management. Raihan Alam, a Rady doctoral student and National Science Foundation graduate research fellow, and psychologist Tage Rai, an assistant professor of management at Rady, ran 10 studies and argue that punishment works less well on people whose misconduct grows out of moral feeling than on people chasing material gain.

For anyone building deterrence policy, the implication is direct: a cost-and-benefit calculation of offending leaves out the motive that tells many offenders they are owed something.

How much does punishment actually deter?

From "three-strikes" laws to longer prison sentences, legislatures impose harsher penalties expecting crime to fall. Decades of research say the effect is often surprisingly small, and the Rady team suggests one reason has been overlooked — what the person in front of them wants in the first place.

Rai said: "Taken together, our findings show that when people are motivated by moral sentiments to commit crimes or transgress, they tend to be less sensitive to punishment than when they're acting for material or selfish reasons."

What did the 10 studies measure?

The program of work ran in tiers, from large-scale data to controlled games:

  • Federal crime data. Researchers analyzed records on more than 30,000 offenders across 29 categories of crime. Crimes that study participants judged more morally motivated went with higher rearrest rates; crimes judged more materially motivated went with lower rates.
  • A 422-person experiment. Participants imagined blocking traffic either to support a cause they believed in or in exchange for money. Those imagining a cause were less deterred by the possible consequences.
  • Further experimental scenarios. The same pattern held across financial penalties, physical harm and social disapproval.
  • Economic games with real money. One player ended up with all available money, either by deliberately keeping it or through random allocation. A second player could redistribute the money evenly, at the risk of a financial penalty.

Without a possible penalty, participants redistributed money at similar rates whether the uneven split was deliberate or random. Add the penalty and the gap appeared: about 20 percentage points more redistribution when the inequality had been engineered rather than accidental. People accepted more risk of punishment when they believed they were correcting an injustice.

Alam said: "People sometimes commit crimes because they feel morally compelled to right a wrong. Or they might be retaliating, punishing someone, defending their honor. That doesn't mean their behavior is justified. It means they're acting on motives that don't fit neatly into a cost-benefit calculation."

How solid are these results?

Three limits deserve naming. The rearrest link rests on study participants' assessments of likely motives rather than offenders' own accounts, so it shows association, not cause. The experiments isolate motive by holding the illegal behavior constant while varying the reason for it; they do not compare harsher sentences against lighter ones head to head. And the causal tests ran on volunteers in experiments and games, not on convicted offenders deciding whether to reoffend.

Does it hold for people with criminal records?

The researchers also ran their core studies with participants who had prior misdemeanor or felony convictions. Results looked remarkably similar to those of the general population. That undercuts a common explanation for punishment's weak track record — that offenders lack self-control, misjudge risk or cannot weigh consequences — and shifts the question to what actually drives their conduct.

What does this change for crime prevention?

Alam and Rai suggest prevention may need to address underlying motivations rather than simply raise penalties. Their studies did not test this directly, but they point to restorative justice, which focuses on repairing harm and relationships, as one possible approach.

Rai framed the open question: "If we're punishing people because we want retribution against those who've done harm, if that's what we want, then punishment's fine. But if the goal is actually to change behavior, then punishment may not be the best tool for the job."

The paper, "Morally motivated crimes are less sensitive to punishment," carries the DOI 10.1073/pnas.2624057123.

One paper, 10 studies, and a sharper question for anyone setting penalties: not only how much punishment, but what the offending is for.

Takeaway: Deterrence arithmetic assumes people offend for material gain, and that assumption fails exactly where penalties are supposed to bite hardest.

via phys.org/rss-feed/ (Source)

Filed under

  • crime-deterrence
  • moral-motivation
  • punishment
  • behavioral-economics
  • restorative-justice
Share this article:

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on general science news at SciBeat.

493 articles

Nearby plates

« Previous articleNext article »