Plate Nº 63 · recorded November 18, 2026
Neuroscience & MindReported finding
Brain-damage study finds the will to empathize survives injury
Patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage chose empathy tasks as often as healthy adults, suggesting social struggles may reflect impaired emotion-reading, not unwillingness.
By Priya Raman4 min read841 words
In brief
- 13 patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage picked the affective empathy deck on 47 percent of trials, versus 37 percent for 16 healthy adults — not a significant difference.
- The study, published in Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, preregistered its hypotheses and posted data and code publicly.
- Affective empathy was chosen on 42 percent of trials and cognitive perspective-taking on 32 percent across all participants.
- With roughly 40 participants, the study fell short of the 120 needed to reliably detect moderate individual-level relationships.
- A companion study of amygdala-damage patients, published in the journal Brain, showed similarly intact empathy motivation.

People with damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex — a brain region behind the forehead long linked to "pseudopsychopathy" — chose empathy-inducing tasks just as often as healthy adults and brain-injured peers. The study, published in Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, suggests injury to this region does not necessarily diminish a person's willingness to step into another's shoes. Instead, everyday empathy struggles after such injuries may stem from trouble reading emotions rather than avoiding empathy.
Since the nineteenth-century case of railroad worker Phineas Gage, who survived an iron rod through his skull, clinicians have observed that damage here often leaves people indifferent to social norms and others' feelings. The region, sitting at the bottom middle of the frontal lobes above the eye sockets, can be injured by trauma, stroke, or tumor removal, triggering dramatic personality shifts while sparing intelligence, memory, and speech. Modern cases, such as a man known in the literature as EVR, whose personality changed after frontal tumor surgery, showed social detachment that clinicians compared to psychopathic traits.
Psychologists separate empathy ability — accurately reading emotions and feeling concern — from empathy motivation, the willingness to enter situations that invite sharing feelings. A 2013 brain-imaging study of incarcerated offenders with psychopathy showed these can split apart: offenders showed muted activity in pain-sharing regions while passively watching people get hurt, yet responded more normally when asked to feel with the person on screen.
"We wanted to isolate whether these deficits of empathy were due to issues of motivation (i.e., 'won't empathize') or ability (i.e., 'can't empathize')," lead author Julian A. Scheffer, an assistant professor of psychology at the University of Western Ontario, told PsyPost.
How the study worked
Scheffer, working with senior author Daniel Tranel and colleagues at the University of Iowa, recruited 13 patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage on one or both sides of the brain, all tested at least three months after injury. They compared them with 13 brain-damaged patients whose injuries spared this region and 16 healthy adults, matched on age, sex, and education. A neurologist unaware of the hypotheses verified all lesion boundaries on brain scans. The team preregistered their hypotheses and posted data and code publicly online.
Participants completed two 40-trial computerized tasks:
- Affective empathy (emotionally sharing feelings): choosing between a blue "FEEL" deck — writing about a child refugee's internal emotions — and a red "DESCRIBE" deck, writing objectively about physical appearance.
- Cognitive empathy (imagining another's perspective): choosing between "FEEL-OTHER" and "FEEL-SELF" decks after viewing emotional photos.
Each round carried a mandatory 10-second wait; four patients with typing difficulties dictated responses to an experimenter. Participants then rated each deck on effort, aversiveness, and efficacy.
What did the numbers show?
Across all participants, people tended to avoid empathy: they picked the affective option on 42 percent of trials and the perspective-taking option on 32 percent. But group differences were not statistically significant. Patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage chose the affective empathy deck on 47 percent of trials, versus 44 percent for brain-damaged comparison patients and 37 percent for healthy adults. In the cognitive task, both brain-injured groups picked perspective-taking on 33 percent of trials, healthy adults on 31 percent.
Bayesian analyses (statistical tests that check whether data actively support equivalence between groups) backed the absence of differences in both tasks, though the cognitive result should be read conservatively because scores departed from a normal distribution. Notably, follow-up comparisons indicated the patient group rated affective empathy as moderately less effortful than healthy adults did — possibly, the authors suggest, because damage blunts emotion-recognition processes that ordinarily make sharing distress feel demanding.
"We were surprised that we did not observe a decrease in empathy motivation in people with vmPFC lesions," Scheffer said. "But this may have further highlighted that prior issues of empathy were on how people with damage to this region successfully deploy empathy."
The broader preregistered project also studied patients with amygdala damage (an almond-shaped emotion structure), reporting separately in the journal Brain similarly intact empathy motivation.
What are the limits?
The study has real constraints. A forced binary choice between two decks could reflect a dislike of describing appearances rather than a desire to empathize. The researchers did not directly test emotion-recognition accuracy in these 13 patients, so they cannot verify impaired ability alongside intact motivation in the same individuals. And with roughly 40 participants, the study fell short of the 120 needed to reliably detect moderate individual-level relationships.
"Someone who can't empathize but is trying may be thought of differently from someone who can empathize but won't," Scheffer said, noting the distinction matters for clinical profiles and caregivers. Future studies could offer accept-or-reject empathy choices, observe patients outside the lab, and measure motivation alongside emotion-reading accuracy in the same participants — work Scheffer's lab is now pursuing, alongside studies of dementia caregivers.
The study was authored by Julian A. Scheffer, Justin Reber, C. Daryl Cameron, and Daniel Tranel.
via psypost.org (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in general science news at SciBeat.
476 articles
Nearby plates
- Childhood abuse linked to brain structure changes in largest neuroimaging study
- One Patient, One Procedure: Right Amygdala Tied to PTSD
- Brain Wiring Pattern May Flag Alzheimer's Risk Years Early
- Consciousness Lives in the Brainstem, Not the Cortex, Scientists Argue
- Brain scan score linked to later Alzheimer’s-related decline