Plate Nº 51 · recorded November 17, 2026
Science Policy & FundingReported finding
COP31 climate loss and damage rules must go beyond borders
COP31 faces a defining choice on climate loss and damage: widen eligibility beyond national labels and let communities apply, researchers argue, as pledges remain tiny beside trillions in annual losses.
By Elena Vasquez4 min read898 words
In brief
- COP27 created the Loss and Damage Fund in 2022; it officially launched in 2023.
- About $770.6 million was pledged at COP28; only a fraction has arrived, and $250 million is set aside for initial grants.
- The 1992 U.N. climate convention’s broad wording would have included nearly all of Africa, the authors say.
- In 2007, parties in Bali narrowed the focus to least developed countries, small island states and drought-, desertification- and flood-affected African countries.
- The researchers argue that COP31 should consider all developing countries and permit direct applications from communities.

By Elena Vasquez
Developed-country parties pledged about $770.6 million at COP28, but only $250 million has been set aside for initial grants as estimated annual climate losses run into trillions of dollars.
Only a fraction of the pledged money has arrived, leaving the fund far too small to meet the cost of existing climate disasters. That makes the definition of “particularly vulnerable” more than a technical drafting choice at COP31: it will determine which countries qualify, which are excluded and how a scarce pool is divided.
A study by a legal academic and a human geographer, based on their analysis of U.N. climate negotiations and relevant texts, finds that eligibility is both a legal and political decision.
The authors write: “But climate change damage does not stop at borders.” Communities facing imminent and irreversible harm may need help recovering and adapting even if their country is not named on an agreed list.
What does “particularly vulnerable” mean?
Governments agreed at COP27 in 2022 to create the Loss and Damage Fund, now called the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage.
The decision was widely seen as a breakthrough for Africa. It also marked the first global recognition that countries contributing little to climate change could not be expected to finance protection measures alone, and established a pathway to help pay for climate damage.
The fund was intended to address losses ranging from destroyed homes and livelihoods to deaths and lost cultural heritage. It officially launched in 2023.
Yet the fund’s eligibility rules remain unsettled. The money is intended for developing countries considered “particularly vulnerable,” but governments have not decided which countries meet that description.
The term can be traced to the 1992 U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change. Its wording covered small island countries, low-lying coasts, arid and semiarid, or partly dry, areas, places prone to floods, drought and desertification, and fragile mountain ecosystems. Read literally, the authors say, it would have included nearly all of Africa.
Over time, the meaning narrowed. At a 2007 meeting in Bali, convention parties said least developed countries, small island states and only African countries affected by drought, desertification and floods were most at risk from climate change.
Takeaway: A country-only rule can exclude exposed communities even when the original climate treaty points to a much broader pool.
Why do country borders mislead?
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the U.N. body that supplies climate science, says vulnerability varies widely between and within regions. It is also shaped by colonialism, inequality, exclusion and governance, so borders or low gross domestic product, a measure of national economic output, cannot reliably identify who faces the greatest harm.
Drought from 2020 to 2023 crossed the Ethiopia-Kenya border in the Horn of Africa. Ethiopia is a least developed country; Kenya has lower-middle-income status. Pastoralist, or herding, families on both sides lost cattle, their main livelihood. This year’s super El Niño is worsening the impact, according to the authors. Yet a system based only on national status would treat them differently.
Risk is concentrated among residents of informal settlements in fast-growing African cities, smallholder farmers, displaced people, women with weaker land rights, older people and children. Local and national government bodies differ in resources and preparedness, which can deepen those inequalities.
Eligibility on paper does not guarantee access. A study of the Green Climate Fund for developing countries found that the capacity to apply for and manage money mattered more than any objective measure of vulnerability. Many highly vulnerable countries received little support.
Research on the Adaptation Fund, which finances projects to help countries adapt to climate harm, found that the ability to apply for and manage money shaped allocations. Low-income countries received more than least developed countries. African governments with stretched institutions may qualify on paper but struggle to reach the money.
Takeaway: Development labels can misdirect aid from communities with the same exposure and fewer resources to recover.
What should African negotiators demand at COP31?
Every five years, the COP global stocktake reviews climate progress and pushes for stronger targets. The COP28 stocktake recognized that vulnerability depends on people’s circumstances, not only their country. The U.N. expert group on least developed countries also agreed, while U.N. Trade and Development recommended the broadest possible definition for the fund.
The researchers argue that African negotiators should resist narrow, country-by-country lists at COP31. All developing countries should be eligible for consideration, as the 1992 wording allows, and funding should reach vulnerable groups within countries.
Communities and local organizations should also be able to apply directly, rather than relying only on governments. Civil society groups have long made this demand. Direct access could help overstretched administrations and reach residents that national systems miss. The authors also argue that government-only distribution wrongly assumes states will protect their most marginalized citizens.
The authors warn that pledged money will not reach every vulnerable person. “A narrow definition of who most needs the funds will likely make the gap between need and support seem smaller than it is,” they write.
A broader, fairer definition would recognize what wealthy nations owe, though even then it would barely repay the debt from historical climate harms.
Takeaway: At COP31, the fairest test is need and exposure, with a route for affected communities to request aid directly.
via phys.org/rss-feed/ (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around general science news at SciBeat.
455 articles