Plate Nº 54 · recorded November 16, 2026

Space & AstronomyReported finding

Dark Energy May Be Weakening, DESI Survey Data Suggest

DESI's three-year map of nearly 50 million galaxies hints dark energy is weakening, challenging the standard model of cosmology and dividing astronomers.

By Priya Raman4 min read892 words

In brief

  1. DESI's March 2025 analysis of three years of data suggests dark energy is weakening by roughly 10 per cent over recent billions of years.
  2. DESI is mapping nearly 50 million galaxies using the 4m Mayall Telescope in Arizona, capturing 5,000 spectra per exposure.
  3. Ordinary matter makes up just 4.9 per cent of the Universe; dark energy accounts for 68.3 per cent.
  4. The team estimates a 1 in 50,000 chance the result is a fluke, but critics say the data remain consistent with the standard model.
  5. Euclid (2023) and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory (2025) will provide independent tests.
Dark energy could be fading – and it might drag the entire Universe down with it
Plate Nº 54Dark energy could be fading – and it might drag the entire Universe down with it — ELG21 / pixabay

Dark energy – the mysterious force driving the Universe apart – may be weakening over time, according to a March 2025 analysis of three years of data from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI). If confirmed, the finding would upend the standard model of cosmology and could even reopen the distant possibility that the Universe will one day collapse in on itself.

The preliminary result comes from an international consortium of almost 1,000 researchers who are building the largest three-dimensional map of the Universe, charting nearly 50 million galaxies. DESI's data suggest the expansion of the Universe is still accelerating, but the rate of acceleration is slowly dwindling – contradicting the prevailing assumption that dark energy is a constant repulsive force.

"I'm very convinced about the result," says Prof Catherine Heymans of the University of Edinburgh, the Astronomer Royal for Scotland. "It was achieved by a mature, experienced, fantastic team with the best technology and telescope that you could use to do this measurement."

Not everyone agrees. "The team claims that there's only a 1 in 50,000 chance of this result being a fluke," says cosmologist Prof George Efstathiou of the University of Cambridge. "I'm more confident than that that their interpretation is wrong."

What is the standard model at stake?

Since 1998, when two independent teams discovered that cosmic expansion is accelerating – a breakthrough that earned their leaders the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics – astronomers have attributed the acceleration to dark energy, represented by the Greek letter lambda (Λ). Combined with cold dark matter (CDM, a type of unseen matter whose 'cold' refers to its slow movement), this forms the ΛCDM model.

In this framework, ordinary matter – galaxies, stars, planets and people – makes up a mere 4.9 per cent of the Universe. Dark energy accounts for 68.3 per cent and dark matter 26.8 per cent. High-precision observations by the European Space Agency's Gaia telescope agree perfectly with ΛCDM, which is why Efstathiou remains "confident it doesn't need to change."

A simple comparison captures the new result. A Formula One driver flooring the accelerator gains speed steadily, as ΛCDM predicts. DESI's data suggest the Universe is instead easing off the pedal: speed still rises, but more and more slowly.

How do you measure the Universe's history?

DESI observes from the 4m Nicholas U. Mayall Telescope at Kitt Peak National Observatory in Arizona. Its robotically repositioned optical fibres capture 5,000 galaxy spectra simultaneously in each 16-minute exposure, feeding ten spectrographs that each record 500 spectra at a time.

The key measurement is redshift (the stretching of light to redder wavelengths as space expands), which tells astronomers how long a galaxy's light has travelled – effectively looking back in time.

DESI also relies on baryon acoustic oscillations (BAOs), subtle statistical patterns in galaxy distribution imprinted by pressure waves in the primordial Universe. These patterns originally spanned 450,000 light-years; after 13.8 billion years of expansion, they now stretch about 490 million light-years. Tracking their growth across 11 billion years of cosmic history reveals the expansion rate. "It's the cleanest probe we have of the evolution of large-scale structures in our Universe," says Heymans.

The five-year survey began in May 2021 and was completed in 2026. A first-year analysis in 2024 already hinted dark energy had weakened by roughly 10 per cent over the past couple of billion years; the three-year results appear to confirm this.

Do supernovae settle the question?

In June 2025, the Supernova Cosmology Project, led by Nobel laureate Prof Saul Perlmutter of UC Berkeley, published an analysis of more than 2,000 Type Ia supernovae – exploding stars whose known true luminosity makes them usable as distance markers. Those data also appear compatible with weakening dark energy.

Yet Efstathiou calls the supernova data "unreliable", noting that Type Ia luminosities depend on age and composition, requiring hard-to-calibrate corrections. Perlmutter himself urged caution: "I don't think anyone is jumping up and down getting overly excited yet... we know that this could go away once we get even better data."

Crucially, DESI data alone, without supernovae, show no greater statistical significance in the three-year analysis than in the one-year result. "Statistically speaking, DESI's three-year data set is still consistent with ΛCDM," says Efstathiou.

What could it mean for the Universe's fate?

If dark energy evolves, physicists may need new particles, forces or even a modified theory of gravity. "There's a zoo of different models out there," says Heymans. The Universe's ending also becomes uncertain: instead of the cold, empty Big Freeze predicted by ΛCDM, expansion could one day halt and reverse into a catastrophic 'Big Crunch'.

Further clarity should come from DESI's final 15-million-galaxy data release, ESA's Euclid space telescope (launched 2023) and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory in Chile, which began operations in early 2025. Euclid team member Prof Koen Kuijken of Leiden Observatory cautions that precise dark energy measurements may only arrive near the end of Euclid's six-year mission.

For now, the standard model stands – barely. As DESI collaborator Prof Ofer Lahav of University College London told The Guardian: "It's fair to say we have no idea what dark matter or dark energy is."

via sciencefocus.com (Source)

Filed under

  • dark-energy
  • desi-survey
  • cosmology
  • universe-expansion
  • cdm
Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in general science news at SciBeat.

425 articles

Nearby plates

« Previous articleNext article »