Plate Nº 79 · recorded November 16, 2026
Science Policy & FundingReported finding
Foster care placements fall short of 1978 federal mandate
Federal analysis of 2018–2023 foster care data found that about half of American Indian and Alaska Native children received preferred placements, with rates ranging from below 20% to above 60%.
By Priya Raman4 min read721 words
In brief
- The Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 sets preferred-placement requirements for AIAN children in foster care.
- Researchers analyzed AFCARS data from 2018–2023 and published the study in 2026.
- About half of American Indian and Alaska Native children in foster care received preferred placements nationally.
- Rates exceeded 60% in some states, fell below 33% in many states and below 20% in some jurisdictions.

Fewer than one in five American Indian and Alaska Native (AIAN) children were in placements preferred under federal law in some jurisdictions during 2018–2023.
At Rutgers University’s School of Criminal Justice, associate professor Frank Edwards helped examine six years of placement records to learn how often states followed the placement sequence established by the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) of 1978.
About half of AIAN children in foster care were placed with kin, meaning relatives, or in Native foster homes. State results differed sharply, so the national average concealed a wide range of outcomes.
What does federal law require?
The 1978 law requires a state that takes an AIAN child into foster care to seek placement first with a family member, a member of the child’s tribal nation or another Native family. The researchers treated those arrangements as preferred placements.
The statute operates as a short placement checklist: family and tribal connections come before nonfamily or non-Native foster care. The study asks whether child-welfare systems consistently reached those options before using nonfamily or non-Native foster homes.
How did researchers measure the gap?
Researchers used the Adoption and Foster Care Analysis and Reporting System (AFCARS), a federal data system, for 2018 through 2023 to identify children’s placements with AIAN relatives or foster caretakers. They then estimated the likelihood of preferred placements nationally and by state.
They also compared those kin-placement patterns with patterns across racial and ethnic groups, placing the AIAN results within a broader child-welfare context. The paper appeared in the journal Children and Youth Services Review in 2026.
Because the analysis estimates patterns in routine government placement records, it cannot by itself show why an individual placement occurred or whether every procedural step in a particular case was completed. Its figures also end with 2023 and do not establish conditions after that year.
How wide was the gap?
- Some states achieved preferred-placement rates above 60%.
- In many states, fewer than 33% of AIAN children were in preferred settings.
- In some jurisdictions, fewer than 20% of AIAN children were in preferred settings.
The spread is consequential because the same federal priority applies across jurisdictions. The study found that AIAN children were often placed in nonfamily and non-Native foster care at rates difficult to reconcile with the law’s stated priorities.
The figures describe uneven application of a common standard, not a single national rate that applies equally everywhere. They identify where stronger compliance should be examined first.
What did the authors conclude?
Frank Edwards said: “The Indian Child Welfare Act established binding federal standards for the placement of Indian children in foster care, prioritizing extended family members, tribal-approved homes and other Indian families when children cannot remain with their parents. Nearly five decades later, it is clear that some states have not consistently honored these federal mandates.”
“Binding” means legally enforceable. Edwards’s warning does not rest on a single low-rate jurisdiction; it rests on sharp variation and repeated failure to meet federal mandates across multiple states.
Theresa Rocha Beardall, associate professor of sociology at the University of Washington, put the next step this way: “Closing the gap between statutory requirements and actual practice will require sustained commitment from federal and state agencies, meaningful partnerships with tribal nations and accountability structures that ensure that compliance is not merely aspirational but achieved in the daily operations of child welfare systems serving Native children and families.”
“Statutory requirements” are duties established by law; “accountability structures” are mechanisms for tracking and enforcing compliance. Beardall tied both to sustained action by federal and state agencies and to meaningful partnerships with tribal nations.
The study can guide action because it locates gaps between legal requirements and recorded practice. States and tribal nations can use that evidence when pressing for stronger compliance and considering changes in policy and practice.
The authors emphasize sustained commitment, tribal partnerships and accountability rather than treating compliance as aspirational. The analysis was published under the title “Promises unfulfilled? National patterns in ICWA-preferred kinship placements, 2018–2023,” with DOI 10.1016/j.childyouth.2026.109187. A DOI, or digital object identifier, is the publication’s unique identifier.
The law has set the standard for nearly five decades; the study shows that some states still have not applied it consistently.
via phys.org/rss-feed/ (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in general science news at SciBeat.
425 articles
Nearby plates
- Missed Pediatric Visits Rose After Chicago ICE Crackdown
- Foreign-born L.A. ER visits fell over 20% after immigration surge
- Washington Post maps damage to U.S. science in Trump's first year
- Trial: 38% liquid arrests decay in more than half of baby teeth
- Financial support for Flint families linked to fewer newborn deaths