Plate Nº 45 · recorded November 17, 2026
Science Policy & FundingReported finding
Workplace Fairness Laws Cut Factory Waste by Nearly 10%, Study Finds
States with employment nondiscrimination acts saw factories cut process waste nearly 10%, Penn State researchers found across 33 years and 8,670 facilities.
By Nathan Brooks4 min read863 words
In brief
- Manufacturing process waste fell nearly 10% at EPA-reporting firms in states with ENDAs.
- The study covered 8,670 facilities under 1,112 parent firms from 1987 to 2019.
- Firms had 57% higher odds of process modifications and ~74% higher odds of using internal knowledge after ENDA enactment.
- The study appears in Production and Operations Management (2026), DOI: 10.1177/10591478261480288.
- No federal sexual-orientation or gender-identity employment protections existed until the 2020 Bostock v. Clayton ruling.

Manufacturing facilities in states that adopted employment nondiscrimination acts, or ENDAs, cut their process waste by nearly 10%. That's the headline finding of a new Penn State-led study published in the journal Production and Operations Management, which examined 33 years of federal pollution data covering more than 8,000 U.S. plants.
The research team tracked 8,670 distinct manufacturing facilities operating under 1,112 parent firms between 1987 and 2019. They compared waste trends in states that enacted ENDAs against states that hadn't yet adopted the policies, drawing on the Environmental Protection Agency's Toxics Release Inventory — a database that tracks chemical releases and the steps facilities take to reduce pollution onsite.
What are ENDAs, and why did states create them?
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 banned employment discrimination based on race, color, religion and national origin. But until the Supreme Court's 2020 ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, there was essentially no federal protection against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity. To fill that gap, many states passed their own ENDAs over the decades.
Because states adopted these laws at different times, the staggered rollout gave researchers the conditions for a natural experiment — one that could help control for other national and regional economic shifts affecting manufacturing.
How did the waste reduction actually happen?
The researchers point to two mechanisms. First, the laws increased the diversity of perspectives inside the workplace. Second, they boosted what organizational scholars call "psychological safety" — a shared sense that employees can speak up without fear of punishment or embarrassment.
That sense of safety makes people more likely to flag problems or suggest improvements, the team said. The numbers back the mechanism: after ENDA enactment, firms had 57% higher odds of making modifications to their manufacturing processes, and roughly 74% higher odds of relying on internal knowledge when making those changes. That internal expertise, the researchers note, may reduce reliance on outside consultants who lack firsthand factory-floor insight.
"Research tells us that if you want to learn, if you want to contribute, you should feel safe," said co-author Suresh Muthulingam, professor of supply chain management at Penn State's Smeal College of Business. "If you are in a stressed-out environment, it is difficult to do that. So, this sense of psychological safety creates an environment where people can voice their ideas, which can lead to improvements in operations."
"Since there were more diverse people in the plant due to these acts — and they felt safer working in that environment — they were more likely to share ideas or question things that might be a bit unconventional or against the mainstream," said co-author Kevin Linderman, professor and chair of Smeal's Department of Supply and Information Systems. "This actually helps the firm learn and improve more over time."
Did the effect differ between plants and headquarters?
Yes, and in a way that surprised the team. The researchers ran two separate analyses: a facility-level look at individual plants within adopting states, and a firm-level analysis of parent companies headquartered there. Even though most production happens at the plant level, ENDA enactment had an even greater effect at the firm level — evidence, the authors say, of how much changes from top management can ripple across an organization. Muthulingam noted that greater diversity at the managerial level and above appears to be an important driver.
"Sometimes it's not easy to look at a solution or identify a problem unless you have different viewpoints," he said. "A more diverse set of people voicing their opinions helps you to surface the problems and possibly identify solutions that can improve your processes."
How confident can we be in the numbers?
The team says it ran a battery of robustness checks to rule out preexisting trends, policy anticipation effects and timing errors. "We conducted a battery of robustness checks to ensure there were no preexisting trends before the policy change, no anticipation of the policies, and that we were accurately capturing the timing of the impacts," said co-author Max Ji, an assistant professor at University College Dublin and a doctoral candidate in Smeal's department. They also incorporated data from the Correlates of State Policy Project, which compiles over a century of state-level policy and socioeconomic data, to separate ENDA effects from other major environmental and labor policy changes.
Still, the study is observational — it identifies strong associations rather than lab-style proof of cause and effect, a standard caveat for natural-experiment research.
What's the bigger picture?
The findings fit a growing thread in operations management research arguing that employee welfare and societal outcomes belong in how we measure organizational success. Muthulingam puts it plainly: take care of employees, and the firm benefits.
"At the end of the day, we are not just machines," he said. "With machines, you can just focus on efficiency, but humans need a little bit more. They need to feel wanted. They need to feel included. They need a place where they can voice their ideas."
Suvrat Dhanorkar of Georgia Tech's Scheller College of Business co-authored the study.
via phys.org/rss-feed/ (Source)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in general science news at SciBeat.
456 articles
Nearby plates
- New Trump Administration Rule Raises Alarm Over US Research
- Five Data Sets, Five Answers: The Uncertainty Behind Nitrogen Pollution Maps
- Five Governors Ask EPA to Waive 2027 Renewable Fuel Rules to Cut Pump Prices
- 6% of Montreal's Mapped Area Sends Half Its Business Food Waste to Dump
- Big Tech Steps Back at COP31 as Data Center Backlash Grows