Plate Nº 36 · recorded November 17, 2026

Space & AstronomyReported finding

Comets Ruled Out as Life's Delivery Service, Model Shows

Cambridge simulations show comet impacts almost always vaporize organic molecules, shifting the search for life's origin to asteroids or Earth itself. Published 28 October.

By James Calloway4 min read741 words

In brief

  1. Organic molecules survive comet impacts only below 33,500 mph (15 km/s), and simulations show comets almost always exceed this on Earth.
  2. The research, led by Richard Anslow of the University of Cambridge, was published on 28 October in Scientific Reports.
  3. OSIRIS-REx samples from asteroid Bennu contained all the building blocks of RNA.
  4. Comet impacts were far more frequent in the solar system's first half-billion years.
  5. Simulations show slightly better organic survival odds on Mars due to its thinner atmosphere and lower gravity.
Did comets bring building blocks of life to Earth? Scientists aren't so sure anymore
Plate Nº 36Did comets bring building blocks of life to Earth? Scientists aren't so sure anymore — TheDigitalArtist / pixabay

For organic molecules to survive a comet impact on Earth, the comet must hit at under 33,500 miles per hour — and new simulations show that almost none of them did. That is the blunt verdict of research led by planetary scientist Richard Anslow of the Institute of Astronomy at the University of Cambridge, published on 28 October in Scientific Reports. After more than a century of suspicion, comets are effectively off the hook as the source of life's building blocks on Earth.

The finding strikes at a long-standing and, by Anslow's own admission, appealing hypothesis. "Historically, scientists thought that comets were important for the origin of life on Earth, because they carried carbon and nitrogen-bearing molecules, so these giant space snowballs were almost like a 'get-out-of-jail-free card' that brought all the molecules a planet would need to seed life," Anslow said in a statement.

What did the researchers actually model?

Life as we know it runs on carbon chemistry. Complex organic molecules — the precursors of nucleobases, amino acids and sugars — must have formed somewhere before biology could begin. The question has always been where: on Earth itself, or in space, delivered by impact.

Anslow's team ran computer simulations covering comet origins, orbital evolution, atmospheric entry and hypervelocity impacts. They tracked hydrogen cyanide as a stand-in for complex organic molecules generally. It's a sensible proxy: hydrogen cyanide shows up frequently in comets and was even detected in the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS.

The results were unkind to the comet hypothesis. Comets, the model shows, travel too fast and enter Earth's atmosphere at too sharp an angle for fragile organic molecules to endure the collision. Mostly, they vaporize. And in the rare cases where something survives, the concentrations are too low to drive any meaningful prebiotic chemistry.

"It would really have to be a one-in-a-million occurrence, because not only would you need an impact at just the right speed and just the right angle, you would also need everything to happen after that point, in terms of the concentration and the speed at which the chemical origins of life got going," Anslow said. "We can't rule out for certain that it happened that way, but it seems to be a really rare occurrence — at best, a one-off fluke."

Note the hedging. This is a simulation study, not a lab experiment or a fossil record. The word "seemingly" is doing real work in the team's conclusion.

What does this change for the origin-of-life debate?

Two alternatives now look stronger. The first is that all the prebiotic chemistry happened on Earth, no cosmic delivery required. The second points to asteroids. Evidence here is tangible: samples returned by the OSIRIS-REx mission from the near-Earth asteroid Bennu contained all the building blocks of RNA.

A caveat, though. Ruling out comets does not prove asteroids did the job, and nobody yet knows whether life on Earth was a fluke or a cosmic routine. A one-off fluke comet delivery, however improbable, remains technically possible.

Could comets have seeded other worlds?

Possibly. The same simulations gave complex organic molecules a slightly better survival chance on Mars, thanks to the Red Planet's thinner atmosphere and lower gravity.

"This is not to say it definitely happened on Mars, of course, but it suggests it would be unlikely if it happened on Earth and didn't happen on Mars," Anslow said. "Or the other, perhaps more likely, alternative is that it didn't happen on either planet."

The more intriguing case involves exoplanets — specifically the tightly packed, multi-planet systems orbiting red dwarf stars such as TRAPPIST-1. In a 2023 paper, Anslow described how comets in such systems could gravitationally bounce from one planet to the next, shedding velocity along the way. A slower comet means a gentler crash, and a gentler crash means organics might actually survive.

So the romantic image of life arriving on a dirty snowball takes a hit on Earth, but keeps a foothold elsewhere in the galaxy. The catch: comet impacts were far more frequent only in the solar system's first half-billion years, when leftover debris from planet formation was still abundant — and nobody can yet say what actually happened during that window. The mystery of life's origin remains open. It has simply lost one of its favorite suspects.

via space.com (Source)

Filed under

  • comets
  • origin-of-life
  • prebiotic-chemistry
  • planetary-impacts
  • astrobiology
Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on general science news at SciBeat.

474 articles

Nearby plates

« Previous articleNext article »