Plate Nº 49 · recorded November 17, 2026
Science Policy & FundingReported finding
Nigerian Group Slams COP31 Electrification Pledge as Toothless
HOMEF rejects COP31's 35×35 electrification pledge in Antalya, demanding a binding phase-out of coal, oil and gas and grant-based climate finance for developing nations.
By Elena Vasquez4 min read728 words
In brief
- HOMEF criticised the first three days of COP31 talks in Antalya, Türkiye
- The COP31 Presidency's 35×35 pledge targets 35% electricity share of energy use by 2035
- HOMEF demands a binding fossil fuel phase-out, calling voluntary roadmaps insufficient
- The group warned about the 2028 Global Stocktake deadline for meaningful action
- HOMEF wants climate finance delivered as grants, not interest-bearing loans

The Health of Mother Earth Foundation has rejected the flagship "35×35" electrification pledge announced at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, calling instead for a binding commitment to phase out coal, oil and gas.
The Nigerian environmental organisation, led by Executive Director Dr. Nnimmo Bassey, criticised the first three days of the UN climate conference for prioritising diplomatic compromise over concrete action.
The "35×35" initiative, unveiled by the COP31 Presidency on Energy Day, aims to raise electricity's share of total energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035. HOMEF says the target means little if the extra power keeps coming from fossil fuels.
"We cannot electrify our way out of a climate crisis while we continue to pour oil and gas into the destruction engine," Bassey said in a statement.
Why does HOMEF oppose the electrification pledge?
The group does not dispute that electrification matters in the energy transition. Its objection is about the source of the electricity. If new generation capacity runs on gas or coal, higher electricity consumption simply produces more greenhouse gas emissions.
HOMEF wants the pledge tied to a clear commitment to renewable energy, with priority given to community-managed energy systems — locally controlled projects rather than centralised corporate ones.
The organisation also flagged transparency problems. No clear list of countries backing the pledge has been published, it said, raising questions about the real political commitment behind the announcement and the influence of oil and gas interests on the negotiations.
Bassey accused fossil fuel-producing countries of blocking stronger negotiating language requiring a transition away from coal, oil and gas. Takeaway: without a renewables requirement and a named list of supporters, the pledge risks becoming another voluntary gesture.
What did Bassey say about the talks?
His language was blunt. Describing the opening days of the conference, he said: "The first three days in Antalya have felt like watching a slow-motion dance where the music is the siren call of our burning planet, yet the dancers, our leaders, refuse to change their steps."
He framed the negotiations as a critical moment for global climate action, arguing that climate impacts, energy market instability and energy poverty all stem from an economic system built on fossil fuel dependence.
What is the Belém-Antalya Mechanism dispute about?
HOMEF called for the Belém-Antalya Mechanism (BAM) — a framework on the COP31 agenda — to be strengthened from an information-sharing platform into an enforceable one.
In its current form, the group argued, the mechanism merely exchanges climate information. It should instead carry effective measures ensuring countries actually fulfil their climate obligations, translating previously agreed climate principles, rights and historical responsibilities into concrete action.
"The core issue is the dangerous reliance on voluntary, non-binding roadmaps," the organisation stated. "The climate catastrophe does not negotiate with industry lobbyists, nor does it respect the timelines of corporate balance sheets."
What about climate finance?
HOMEF raised a separate concern: the growing reliance on loans to fund climate mitigation and adaptation in developing countries.
Loans, especially interest-bearing ones, deepen the debt burden of nations that contributed least to global emissions yet face some of the worst climate impacts, the group argued.
Its alternative is simple. Climate finance should come primarily through grants and public funding, directed at genuine mitigation and adaptation needs — not at projects serving private commercial interests dressed up as green investment.
What happens next?
Looking ahead to the 2028 Global Stocktake — the UN's scheduled review of collective climate progress — HOMEF warned that the window for meaningful intervention is closing fast.
It urged governments to use COP31 to set a transparent, equitable pathway for phasing out coal, oil and gas, rather than leaning on long-term voluntary commitments. Bassey said real action requires the political courage to halt fossil fuel extraction and to put vulnerable communities and ecosystems ahead of corporate profits.
The transition, the group stressed, must start immediately and be guided by equity, climate justice and protection of both vulnerable populations and the natural environment.
"We are not interested in promises for 2050; we are demanding a transparent, equity-based phase-out of coal, oil, and gas starting today," HOMEF declared.
The demands land at a conference still in its opening week, with delegates facing mounting pressure to move beyond pledges. Whether COP31 delivers binding language on fossil fuels remains the central question of the talks.
via environewsnigeria.com (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around general science news at SciBeat.
503 articles
Nearby plates
- COP31 Launches 35-by-35 Pledge to Electrify the World Economy
- COP31 Week Two Opens With Finance and Fossil Fuel Deadlocks Unresolved
- Ministers Press Türkiye and Australia to Advance Fossil Fuel Exit Roadmap
- Türkiye Launches Biogas Declaration 2026 at COP31 Climate Talks
- COP31 opens with climate finance clash and muted outlook