Plate Nº 26 · recorded November 17, 2026

Earth & ClimateReported finding

A Pile of Old Rubble Delayed Switzerland's 2023 Brienz Rockslide

A month-long delay between evacuation and collapse at Brienz/Brinzauls came down to old rubble. The talus slope braked the rockslide — but only in fits, wrecking forecasts.

By James Calloway3 min read647 words

In brief

  1. Around 1.2 million cubic meters of rock slid toward Brienz/Brinzauls at 11:38 p.m. on June 15, 2023.
  2. Authorities evacuated the village on May 12, 2023 — more than a month before the actual slide.
  3. A talus slope at the foot of the 'Insel' rock mass repeatedly slowed and then released the slide's acceleration.
  4. Robert Kenner (WSL/SLF) and colleagues published the findings in Engineering Geology.
  5. Fluctuating acceleration ran from early March to mid-June 2023, making precise failure forecasts 'hardly possible.'
An old talus slope delayed the 2023 Brienz/Brinzauls rockslide by several weeks
Plate Nº 26An old talus slope delayed the 2023 Brienz/Brinzauls rockslide by several weeks — TeeFarm / pixabay

Roughly 1.2 million cubic meters of rock and debris slid toward the Swiss village of Brienz/Brinzauls on the night of June 15, 2023 — a full month after authorities ordered residents out because a collapse seemed imminent. A team led by Robert Kenner of the WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF has now worked out why the mountain kept everyone waiting. Their study appears in the journal Engineering Geology.

The answer, in short: an old talus slope got in the way. A talus slope is simply a heap of broken rock that has accumulated, piece by piece, at the foot of a cliff over centuries. The unstable rock mass above Brienz — known locally as the "Insel," or "island," because it moved much faster than its surroundings — slid into that heap rather than straight downhill, and the heap pushed back.

Why did the forecast fail?

Officials ordered the evacuation on May 12, 2023, when early warning systems suggested a rapid slide was close. It was not. The Insel had begun accelerating in early March, and that kind of acceleration normally follows a predictable script.

"Typically, a collapse is preceded by an exponential acceleration, which usually allows experts to predict accurately when the event will occur," Kenner explained. That pattern failed here, and the failure matters far beyond one Alpine valley.

"This example is particularly relevant to how we manage natural hazards, as it shows how quickly a process can deviate from its previous or calculated behavior," Kenner said.

How does rubble act as a brake?

The braking was real, but it was not steady, and that is the crux of the story. At first, the Insel shoved the uppermost layer of the talus over the material beneath it, which gradually slowed the rock mass down.

After a few days, the situation flipped. A new sliding surface formed deeper within the talus, the braking weakened, and the Insel sped up again. This back-and-forth repeated several times, and computer simulations by the team reproduced it: each new sliding surface inside the talus temporarily restored the Insel's acceleration.

The researchers watched these acceleration fluctuations drag on from early March to mid-June. "Precise forecasts of when the slope would fail were therefore hardly possible," Kenner said.

What happened on the night itself?

The pattern broke on the morning of June 15, 2023 — but not in a tidy way. Only the eastern part of the Insel slid into the talus slope. The western part held its ground and began pulling on the falling eastern section. That tension eventually tore the western part loose.

Then came a strange reversal. The eastern section stopped, because its mass alone could no longer shove the talus ahead of it. The remaining rock accelerated sharply, transformed into flowing debris, and surged toward the village at 11:38 p.m. on June 15. It narrowly missed the houses.

What does this change for hazard forecasting?

For a start, it flags a blind spot. "This example highlights the limitations of commonly used approaches to predicting when such an event will occur," Kenner said, summarizing the study. One key lesson, he added, is that in critical situations analysts must pay particular attention to the buttressing effect of talus deposits at the foot of a rock face — that is, the way old rubble can physically prop up and slow an unstable mass above it.

The caveat writes itself. This is one slope, in one valley, with one unusual talus geometry, and the researchers modeled it after the fact. It does not tell you the next mountain will stall for weeks too.

Still, the context is sobering. The larger Brienz/Brinzauls landslide, which runs from the River Albula on the valley floor high up the mountainside, has been known for centuries. The evacuation, as Kenner concludes, is what kept this unpredictable sequence from becoming a tragedy.

via phys.org/rss-feed/ (Source)

Filed under

  • landslide
  • rockslide
  • talus-slope
  • natural-hazards
  • switzerland
Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on general science news at SciBeat.

474 articles

Nearby plates

« Previous articleNext article »