Plate Nº 87 · recorded November 16, 2026
Biology & EvolutionReported finding
First 'Dark Magic Mushroom' Makes Psilocybin and Deadly Toisons
Scientists have identified the first mushroom making both psilocybin and deadly amatoxins — and it bruises blue, upending a common forager rule of thumb.
By James Calloway4 min read700 words
In brief
- *Galerina indica* is the first known mushroom to contain both psilocybin and amatoxins, per a study in *Current Biology*.
- The species was first discovered in India over a decade ago; the new specimens came from a palm trunk in Florida wetlands.
- The dual chemistry likely arose from two independent horizontal gene transfer events in the *Galerina* genus.
- The mushroom bruises blue when handled, previously considered a sign of psilocybin rather than amatoxins.
- The study does not confirm whether *G. indica*'s toxin levels are lethal to humans.

For the first time on record, scientists have found a single mushroom that produces both psilocybin — the hallucinogen behind so-called magic mushrooms — and amatoxins, the poisons that make death caps the deadliest fungi on Earth. The species is Galerina indica, and the researchers describe their find in Current Biology.
Fungal biologist Andrew Kunik, who completed the work while at the University of Florida and is now at Harvard, put it plainly: "We matched up our findings and confirmed that we saw both compounds." His first reaction? Disbelief. "I could hardly believe it. We knew it was possible but tried not to get too excited until we did a more rigorous analysis."
That rigor involved chemical analysis of the specimens and full genome sequencing. The mushroom itself has a history. It was first discovered in India over a decade ago, but nobody knew its chemical double life until Kunik and colleagues examined specimens clinging to a moss-covered palm trunk in Florida's wetlands.
What exactly is this mushroom?
G. indica belongs to the Galerina genus — not the Amanita family of the infamous death cap, but a related rogue's gallery nonetheless. Its cousins include the Galerina marginata species complex, better known as 'funeral bells' and 'deadly skullcaps'. The nicknames are earned.
Until now, no known mushroom sat in both camps at once. Toxic species existed. Psychedelic species existed. A species packing both chemicals was unheard of, which is precisely why the researchers call it the world's first "dark magic mushroom."
How did it end up with both?
Here the story gets stranger. Mushroom-forming fungi usually inherit the genes for their specialized chemicals from their ancestors, the way you inherited your eye color. G. indica broke that rule.
The team's genomic work points to horizontal gene transfer — genes moving between organisms rather than passing from parent to offspring. Co-author Bryn Dentinger, a mycologist at the University of Utah, offered a hand-shake analogy: "Horizontal gene transfer is like if we shook hands and some of my DNA incorporated into your genome."
And it happened twice. The researchers think an ancestor of G. indica, already making amatoxins, picked up the genes for psilocybin through one such transfer. A separate Galerina lineage appears to have independently acquired the same capability. "Two independent horizontal gene transfer events for these specialized metabolites in one mushroom genus are unheard of," Dentinger said.
What does this change for foragers?
Potentially a lot, and none of it good. Many foragers treat blue bruising — the color a mushroom develops when handled — as a sign of psilocybin and, by extension, safety. That heuristic is now officially broken.
G. indica develops blue bruising and carries amatoxins at the same time. The researchers are explicit in their paper: "Our finding cautions against interpreting blue bruising as evidence that an uncharacterized psiloid-containing mushroom is free of amatoxins."
One honest caveat. The study does not establish whether the toxin levels in G. indica are actually dangerous or deadly to humans. Unknown is not the same as safe, and nobody should treat it as a green light.
Why would a mushroom do this?
Nobody knows — and the researchers admit it. "We still don't fully understand why mushrooms produce psilocybin," Kunik said. "Amatoxins may help protect mushrooms from animals that eat them, but their precise ecological role isn't entirely clear either. That's what makes the discovery of the 'dark magic mushroom' so interesting. Why would a mushroom produce both of these compounds, and what advantage might that give it in nature?"
The team's best guess is a diversified defense strategy: distinct combinations of toxic compounds might slow down or deter animals that feed on the fungi. That's a hypothesis, not a conclusion. The ecological work hasn't been done.
So the ledger reads like this. One mushroom, two chemical weapons systems, two rare gene-swapping events, and one field identification rule sent to the scrapheap. The study is preliminary in the sense that the ecological questions remain wide open. But the public-health implication doesn't wait for further research: blue bruising no longer means what foragers thought it meant. Don't eat strange mushrooms.
via sciencealert.com (Source)
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on general science news at SciBeat.
399 articles
Nearby plates
- Florida mushroom contains both psilocybin and toxic amatoxins
- D. rex: The 2.2 kg Fungus That Rose After the Dinosaurs Fell
- Single Magic Mushroom Dose Can Anatomically Change the Brain
- Museum Frogs Solve a 50-Year Mystery of Brazil's Vanishing Amphibians
- Supernatural delusions drove 177 psychedelic-linked killings, studies find