Plate Nº 84 · recorded November 16, 2026
Biology & EvolutionReported finding
Important Genes Get No Special Protection From Mutation, Study Finds
Bath biologists mapped ~8,200 mutations in E. coli and yeast and found no shield for essential genes — just 'ghost mutations' weeded out by natural selection.
By Nathan Brooks4 min read702 words
In brief
- Researchers mapped ~3,600 mutations in E. coli and ~4,600 in yeast, calling it the largest, cleanest sample to date
- The study, by Laurence Hurst and Sofia Radrizzani of the University of Bath, appears in PLOS Biology
- A 2022 Max Planck study in thale cress claimed the opposite; a 2023 re-analysis disputed its sequencing methods
- The 'protected genes' idea traces back to biologist Edward Cox in 1972
- Natural selection removing harmful mutations may create 'ghost mutation' illusions of protection

A new analysis of roughly 8,200 spontaneous mutations has found no evidence that evolution "protects" important genes from random change. University of Bath biologists Laurence Hurst and Sofia Radrizzani published the results in PLOS Biology, and their verdict is blunt: the textbook model of evolution stands.
"The claim that mutation is slower for important genes is a triumph of hype over substance," Radrizzani said. "It's a really old suggestion and is reinvented in various forms routinely."
What did the researchers actually test?
The question dates back to 1972, when biologist Edward Cox proposed that some gene sequences enjoy extra shielding from mutation depending on how essential they are. "By assuming that spontaneous mutation rates vary sequence by sequence, one can arrive at a plausible organizing principle for the structure of higher chromosomes," Cox wrote at the time.
Cox's idea never became mainstream, but it keeps resurfacing. In 2022, a team led by J. Grey Monroe of the Max Planck Institute for Biology Tübingen in Germany published evidence that mutations were less frequent in the "important" stretches of DNA in thale cress, a small plant biologists know as Arabidopsis thaliana.
That paper didn't survive scrutiny. In 2023, scientists from Nanjing University in China and the University of Bath re-analyzed the data and couldn't reproduce the results, pointing to errors in how Monroe's team had sequenced the DNA. Monroe's group corrected part of their paper but held their ground. "Although we overlooked some sources of errors, these are insufficient to invalidate our conclusions," they wrote in a reply.
How big was the new experiment?
Hurst and Radrizzani sidestepped the plant debate entirely. They pulled existing mutation data from two workhorse lab organisms: the E. coli bacterium and baker's yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Both had been bred for many generations under minimal external pressure, letting mutations pile up naturally.
In total, the pair mapped the genome positions of about 3,600 mutations in E. coli and 4,600 in yeast — which they describe as the "largest and cleanest" mutation sample assembled so far. They then ranked each gene by how essential it is, using measures like how heavily the microbe relies on it and whether the organism can survive without it.
"Analyze the data any which way and we found nothing," Hurst said. "In neither species did these key genes have a lower mutation rate."
What did move the mutation rate?
The only factors that reliably raised a gene's mutation odds were structural, not functional. When a cell copies its DNA, it duplicates some genes later than others. In yeast, genes copied late in that process did tend to mutate more often.
Beyond that, the researchers checked genes from every angle of "importance": genes that produce abundant proteins, genes long shaped by natural selection, and genes essential to cell survival. None showed reduced mutation rates.
"While we see known causes of variation in mutation rates, we found no evidence for the effects that have been proposed as a challenge to the conventional model," Hurst said. "There are certainly no grounds for a shift in paradigm."
So why did earlier studies see a difference?
Hurst has a proposed answer, and it's a sampling problem. Organisms carrying mutations in their most important genes often don't live long enough for anyone to find them.
"We'd expect natural selection to rapidly remove mutations when they occur in more important genes, because these mutations are more likely to be harmful to the organism," he said.
"This can create the illusion that important genes have fewer mutations when, in reality, some mutations have simply disappeared before we have a chance to analyze them — what you can think of as 'ghost mutations.'"
In other words, the important genes aren't mutating less. Their worst mutations are just dying quietly before scientists can count them.
The findings come with the usual caveats: two microbial species can't rule out every quirk of every genome, and the thale cress dispute remains formally unresolved. But for now, one of evolution's oldest and simplest premises — mutations happen at random, regardless of a gene's importance — looks safer than it has in a decade.
via sciencealert.com (Source)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in general science news at SciBeat.
393 articles
Nearby plates
- Largest mutation study challenges claim vital genes mutate less
- Tracking a 100-million-year-old genome duplication in salmonids
- New RNA Testing Guidance Could Deliver Clearer Genetic Diagnoses
- Neanderthal DNA in Your Genome Follows a 200,000-Year-Old Pattern
- Some Healthy Organs Carry Cancer-Level Mutation Counts, Study Finds