Plate Nº 63 · recorded November 17, 2026
Earth & ClimateReported finding
Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement Needs a Trustworthy Measurement Chain
Ocean alkalinity enhancement may store atmospheric carbon dioxide, but scientists lack a fully traceable way to measure its effects. Rigorous reference materials and monitoring rules must come first.
By Elena Vasquez5 min read1,006 words
In brief
- The Paris Agreement was adopted in 2015 and targets warming well below 2°C by 2100.
- The current Pacific seawater reference material covers one total-alkalinity value, about 2,200 micromoles per kilogram.
- Single-laboratory reference-material production stopped during the COVID-19 pandemic, exposing a system vulnerability.
- A 2026 study developed an artificial total-alkalinity reference material that can be produced at any desired value.
- Scientists have not yet established a comprehensive, robust traceability chain for seawater total-alkalinity measurements.

By Elena Vasquez
A 2026 Eos opinion article identifies a central gap in ocean alkalinity enhancement: scientists lack a fully traceable measurement chain for the seawater changes needed to verify carbon removal.
The Paris Agreement, adopted in 2015, seeks to limit warming by 2100 to well below 2°C above preindustrial levels. Meeting that goal requires at least a balance in which greenhouse gas emissions equal removals by natural sinks and technologies, and may require net-negative removals.
What does ocean alkalinity enhancement promise?
Ocean alkalinity enhancement, or OAE, is a nonbiological form of marine carbon dioxide removal, or mCDR. It adds alkaline substances from natural minerals, human-made chemicals or industrial waste to seawater.
The additions change seawater chemistry, lowering its carbon dioxide concentration and enabling it to absorb more CO₂ from the atmosphere. They also increase buffering capacity, meaning the water can neutralize acids before pH, the scale used to measure acidity, changes substantially. This may help reduce ocean acidification.
The approach shows potential, not a settled solution. Scientists have not fully established methods for measuring and monitoring OAE’s effects, including possible biochemical and ecological side effects and the efficiency of long-term carbon storage.
Expanding mining for alkaline minerals could also cause air and water pollution and local demographic changes. Because mCDR’s scalability remains unproven, deployment must not distract from urgent carbon dioxide cuts.
For now, ocean carbon removal cannot substitute for emissions reductions.
How will carbon removal be counted?\n
A robust monitoring, reporting and verification system, or MRV, is needed to determine how much atmospheric CO₂ an intervention removes. This matters as carbon-credit markets develop, although the existing carbon-credit market is poorly regulated and some companies already use mCDR at relatively small scales.
Gaëlle Capitaine, Paola Fisicaro and Thibaut Wagener, authors of the 2026 analysis, put the priority plainly: “Rigorous sets of rules must apply for mCDR and must ensure that the amount of CO₂ removed from the atmosphere by mCDR practices is thoroughly quantified.”
OAE and other mCDR projects will increasingly face country-specific legal regimes. International instruments such as the London Convention and Protocol offer a minimum set of rules, and legal metrology could help ensure large-scale compliance.
Legal metrology applies statutory controls and enforcement to measurement so results remain reliable, comparable and internationally recognized. It relies on traceability to the International System of Units, regulation of measuring instruments, and certification and standardization by recognized organizations.
Legal-metrology legislation is one pillar of the European Union’s single market for goods.
National metrology institutes ensure that measurements remain comparable across space and time. Under the International Organization of Legal Metrology framework, measurements of substances in water, soil and air can carry greater confidence when assessing the effects of human activities.
Accurate data need an explicit uncertainty budget, defined as an assessment of all sources of variation or error in a measurement. Comparable results also require adherence to metrology principles.
Without common rules, carbon-removal claims cannot be compared or trusted.
Why total alkalinity is the critical test
Total alkalinity, or TA, measures seawater’s capacity to neutralize acids and is recommended for tracking OAE. Before deployment, short-term TA checks quantify background alkalinity; afterward, they help assess efficiency. Combined with other measurements of the marine carbonate system—the reactions linking seawater, carbon dioxide and acidity—TA lets researchers compute key carbon-chemistry values and validate numerical performance models.
Open-ocean diffusion produces very small TA changes. Models estimate those changes, but researchers should confirm them as much as possible with measurements made in the water. This exposes a metrological gap: scientists have not yet established a comprehensive, robust traceability chain for TA.
Researchers currently validate TA methods with reference materials from the Scripps Institution of Oceanography. These are stabilized samples of natural Pacific seawater developed for seawater CO₂ measurements, and they also support TA quality control. Their work has improved comparability worldwide, but the materials are not fully traceable.
One problem is the missing uncertainty budget for the assigned TA value. A standard deviation calculated from a finite number of analyses gives an estimate of precision, but it does not list every possible source of error. A complete budget is needed to establish trueness, meaning closeness to the correct value.
A second problem is dependence on one laboratory to produce the material. A disruption during the COVID-19 pandemic halted production, showing how a single point of failure can stop the system. The material also covers only one TA value for Pacific seawater, about 2,200 micromoles per kilogram.
That single value cannot provide quality controls for the different salinity, carbon and TA conditions around the globe. A stronger system would include an artificial reference material and a stabilized natural seawater with a TA value different from Scripps’s product.
Both need a traceable reference method and a thoroughly quantified uncertainty budget. Work published by the same team in Ocean Science in 2026, volume 22, pages 75–99, produced an artificial material that can be made at any desired TA value. That flexibility could support monitoring above typical natural levels.
National metrology institutes should preferably characterize reference materials because they preserve international comparability. Japan’s National Metrology Institute, Brazil’s National Institute of Metrology, Standardization and Industrial Quality and the Czech Metrology Institute have globally recognized capabilities for measuring sodium carbonate.
Today’s materials help laboratories compare results, but they do not provide a complete global verification network.
Can measurement rules arrive before carbon markets?
Capitaine, Fisicaro and Wagener warn: “We are currently building carbon markets faster than we are building the measurement systems that should underpin them.”
Rigorous metrology could support scientific assessments of OAE, public debate over its viability and legal oversight of carbon credits. It would also strengthen ocean carbon observations more broadly. Without traceable measurements of TA and other seawater variables, society could miss OAE’s promise because it cannot verify or regulate claimed removals.
The bottom line: trustworthy numbers must come before large-scale deployment and carbon-credit claims.
via eos.org/feed (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around general science news at SciBeat.
503 articles
Nearby plates
- Ocean acidification linked to declines in a coastal food chain
- Ocean Carbon Sink Grows While Land Uptake Stalls, 30-Year Data Show
- COP31 Launches Global Seaweed Breakthrough as 70% Decline Looms
- Weddell Sea deep water carries stable organic carbon, study finds
- Rain may raise ocean carbon uptake by 13.6%, study finds